EN ES AR
f t i y
The Gaming Magazine

Building a retro gaming machine: Pi vs. FPGA

A retro gaming machine can recreate the games you remember, or reproduce the behaviour of the original hardware closely enough to feel familiar. Raspberry Pi builds favour flexibility, broad controller support and the ability to assemble everything from inexpensive parts. Field-programmable gate array, or FPGA, systems offer greater hardware accuracy but usually cost more and require more consideration before buying.

For Australian players, the choice also involves PAL video, 50Hz mains power, local import rules and the practical realities of shipping hardware from overseas. The best platform is not necessarily the most technically advanced one. It is the system that suits your games, display, preferred controls and willingness to configure software.

What the two approaches actually run

A Raspberry Pi runs a general-purpose operating system, usually Linux, with emulation software installed on top. RetroPie and similar packages provide menus, artwork, controller mapping and the individual emulators needed for consoles, arcade machines, computers and handheld systems. You can connect a USB controller, arcade stick, trackball or even a conventional keyboard and mouse.

FPGA hardware behaves differently. Instead of asking a modern processor to imitate every circuit, an FPGA configuration implements many of a console’s original characteristics directly. This can produce more authentic video timing, audio, input behaviour and expansion support. The result often resembles the source hardware more closely than a software emulator, although no recreation is completely identical to the machine it references.

This difference matters most for players who care about timing or own peripherals designed for a particular system. A Pi is excellent for collecting several generations in one enclosure, while an FPGA device makes more sense when one platform, its accessories and its visual presentation are the main priorities.

Choosing a Raspberry Pi for flexibility

A Pi 4 or Pi 5 provides enough processing power for most 16-bit and 32-bit libraries, while a Pi Zero 2 can handle simpler systems when size matters. The board itself is only the beginning: you will also need a dependable power supply, microSD card or storage, a suitable case, cooling where necessary and a way to connect video and audio.

Wireless gamepads can make setup convenient, but adapter quality varies. For less common wireless formats, a guide to wireless controller cards can help identify what is needed before you purchase several receivers and discover they use incompatible protocols. Wired USB pads generally provide the least troublesome connection, and original-style controllers can be used through inexpensive interface boards.

The major advantage is that everything can live in one box. EmulationStation can present your library as though it were a multi-arcade cabinet, with separate collections for each console and platform. This makes a Pi suitable for parties, family rooms and players who want access to many styles of game rather than a single carefully recreated machine.

Where FPGA justifies the premium

Devices such as the Analogue Pocket, MiSTer and ZX Spectrum Next sit in a different category because their core behaviour is implemented through programmable logic. The Analogue Pocket is particularly useful for portable play, while a fully equipped MiSTer can reproduce several classic home computers and arcade hardware families. The Spectrum Next serves a different purpose again, combining FPGA technology with modern conveniences.

Hardware accuracy can be especially noticeable with unusual controllers, light pens, expansion hardware and timing-sensitive titles. Audio channels, sprite movement and video refresh can behave in ways that software emulation only approximates. For some enthusiasts, that level of consistency matters more than having dozens of unrelated systems available through one menu.

The trade-off is platform focus. An FPGA device may not cover the broad library of a Pi, and some core collections require licensed hardware or separate add-on boards. Prices also rise quickly when a package includes a screen, controls and original-style ports. Buy based on the specific machine you want to revisit, not on claims that one device is universally more authentic.

Matching displays, power and regional standards

Most Australian retro consoles and computers produced for this market used PAL-B or PAL-G video at 50Hz. An Australian television can therefore be a natural match, whereas an imported NTSC console may produce motion that looks unstable on a 50Hz display. Modern flat-panel televisions add another layer: their scalers may not present 240p signals cleanly and may introduce unwanted processing or audio delay.

A small CRT television fitted with the right inputs can provide an authentic-looking picture, but adding a console to a second-hand CRT involves checking signal compatibility, geometry and safe connector types. Component and RGB modifications are capable of improving the image, yet they also require technical skill and suitable test equipment. Many players begin with a good scaler or a television capable of handling the console’s native output.

Power needs simpler attention. Australian mains electricity runs at 230 volts and generally uses Type I plugs. Pi power supplies are commonly micro-USB or USB-C, so a correctly rated adapter with an appropriate Type I plug is needed. Adapters that support both 230 and 115 volts are convenient for imported hardware, but the output voltage and current must still match the device. Connecting the wrong supply can cause damage that no amount of careful case design will prevent.

Getting the controls and cabinet right

Original controllers often feel better when their original layout is preserved, but many modern pads are more comfortable for longer sessions. USB support lets a Pi use current controllers without much configuration, while FPGA products frequently include ports for the hardware they emulate. Arcade sticks and fighting-game levers need their own interface, and button calibration can take longer than assembling the computer itself.

Mouse and keyboard setups deserve consideration for first-person shooters, strategy games and arcade titles with unusual input methods. This explanation of mouse and keyboard habits shows why some players prefer pointing devices even when a console version is available. The best arrangement usually mixes familiar modern inputs with original accessories where authenticity matters.

A homemade cabinet can look impressive, but its controls and internal layout need to be planned before timber is cut. Leave room for cable bending, ventilation and access to the storage device. Measure the display area rather than relying on screen diagonal measurements, and test the entire control panel before fixing it permanently inside the enclosure.

Adding storage and arcade-inspired extras

Pi systems benefit from fast microSD cards, though USB storage is often easier to replace and can feel more responsive. Separate the operating system, saved games and any large media collection across multiple drives, then create a backup before changing emulator settings. Frontends can scan suitable folders automatically, but naming conventions and metadata files still cause occasional troubleshooting.

FPGA builds use microSD cards, flash storage or internal memory depending on the platform. Files should be copied to a host computer before transfer so that the directory structure remains intact. Licensed games, homebrew and freely available demos should be kept separate, and owners should check the copyright status of any transferred software in their region rather than assuming every copy is authorised.

Arcade racing games open another avenue for decorative additions. The influence of Dubai car culture can be seen in colourful liveries, illuminated trim and carefully coordinated racing mods. A wheel, force-feedback unit and compact seat can turn an ordinary television setup into a convincing driving station, provided the room has enough clearance and the hardware is supported.

Planning for Australian collectors

Local purchases reduce shipping costs, import uncertainty and the risk of a parcel arriving with damaged connectors. Sydney and Melbourne have active retro-gaming communities, specialist sellers and regular collector events, while platforms such as Gumtree Australia can reveal second-hand Pi boards, CRT televisions and discontinued controllers. Searching in Australian dollars also makes it easier to compare a local listing against overseas prices.

Imported orders deserve extra attention. Eligible low-value goods under the A$1,000 threshold can attract GST when they enter Australia, while higher-value consignments may also attract customs charges. The platform or seller may collect some charges, but responsibility can vary according to the transaction. Check the declared value and obtain an invoice before paying, particularly for a custom FPGA board or a fragile CRT.

Housing needs to suit Australian conditions as well. Hot Sydney and Melbourne summers can raise the temperature inside a sealed wooden cabinet, so quiet fans and generous ventilation may be more useful than elaborate lighting. Surge protection, labelled cables and removable storage make servicing easier. Before transporting valuable equipment, compare the exclusions in a home policy using insurance comparison tools, then confirm whether accidental damage during transit is covered.

Choose a Pi when library breadth, arcade flexibility and custom controls matter most. Choose FPGA hardware when faithful timing and a deep connection to one classic platform are the priority. Set a budget in Australian dollars, list every required component, secure the display and controller decisions before ordering, and begin the build with the legal software and accessories you already own.